The Pacific: Review 1&2

A little under nine years after the HBO masterpiece Band of Brothers graced the screen, a second HBO, Playtone and Dreamworks production introduced itself. The Pacific, premiered in the States on March 14, 2010.

Described as a companion piece to ‘Band’, this televisual feast followed three Marines. Robert Leckie, Eugene Sledge and John Basilone. All were in the 1st Marine Division. Leckie in the 1st, Sledge in the 5th and Basilone in the 7th regiment.

Episode 1: Guadalcanal/Leckie

The Pacific, a World War II miniseries, is renowned for its intense portrayal of the Pacific Theatre of War. Episode 1, titled “Guadalcanal/Leckie,” introduces viewers to the brutal realities faced by American soldiers as they engage in combat against the Japanese forces. This episode not only serves as a captivating opening but also sets the tone for the series by highlighting the raw emotions, challenges, and camaraderie experienced by the Marines.

The episode opens with a scene of serene island life before plunging viewers into the chaos of battle. This jarring contrast effectively captures the abrupt disruption of normalcy brought about by war, how life can be changed instantaneously. The opening sequence sets the stage, and hands the viewer has a front row seat. It also demonstrates the psychological impact of combat on the soldiers, as the peaceful moments are soon shattered by explosions, gunfire, and the horrifying sights of war.

A central theme  is the portrayal of the Marines’ internal struggles. The character Robert Leckie, played by James Badge Dale, serves as a lens through which viewers witness the emotional toll of warfare. Through Leckie, the audience experiences the trauma and moral dilemmas faced by soldiers. His internal monologues provide insight into the internal conflict between maintaining humanity while being forced to commit acts of violence.

The production team’s attention to historical accuracy is commendable. The episode portrays the harsh living conditions, physical exhaustion, and psychological strain endured by soldiers on the island. The visceral depiction of disease, discomfort, and the constant threat of death emphasises the unglamorous reality of war, shattering any romanticised notions. While war movies can sometimes be romanticised and given a Hollywood treatment, this has not. Brutality, exhaustion and more serve to remind the viewer what they are watching.

The cinematography and direction in this episode are noteworthy. The handheld camera work immerses the audience in the chaos of battle, creating a sense of immediacy and urgency. The shots of soldiers’ faces capture their fear, determination, and exhaustion, making their emotional journey tangible to viewers. Additionally, the strategic use of sound design enhances the impact of combat scenes, effectively conveying the disorienting and overwhelming nature of battle.

The relationship between comrades-in-arms is a significant aspect of the episode. The bonds formed between soldiers under extreme circumstances highlight the importance of brotherhood as a coping mechanism. This camaraderie is exemplified in Leckie’s interactions with fellow Marines, providing moments of levity and shared humanity amidst the brutality.

Critics of the episode might argue that it occasionally relies on war clichés or archetypes. The gruff but wise sergeant, the idealistic newcomer, and the battle-hardened veteran are characters commonly seen in war. However, The Pacific does attempt to imbue these characters with depth and nuance, giving them individual motivations and struggles that transcend mere stereotypes.

Episode 1 of The Pacific serves as a gripping introduction to the series, effectively conveying the harsh realities of war while delving into the emotional and psychological toll it takes on soldiers. The thematic exploration of internal conflict, camaraderie, and the human cost of combat enriches the viewing experience. The meticulous attention to historical accuracy and the immersive visual and auditory techniques used in the episode contribute to its impact. While not entirely free from war narrative conventions, the episode successfully engages viewers with its compelling storytelling and complex character portrayals.

Episode 2: Basilone

Episode Two  is a poignant exploration of the harsh realities faced by American Marines during World War II. This episode, titled “Basilone,” focuses on the experiences of Sgt. John Basilone, a Medal of Honour recipient who played a crucial role in the Battle of Guadalcanal.

At the core of this episode is the portrayal of the brutal and unrelenting nature of warfare. The opening scene thrusts viewers into the chaos of battle, showcasing the deafening sounds of artillery, the suffocating fear among soldiers, and the disorienting barrage of gunfire. This sensory overload creates a visceral experience that effectively communicates the sheer horror of combat.

The character of Sgt. Basilone serves as a symbol of heroism and sacrifice. Through his actions and interactions, the episode delves into the psychological toll of war on soldiers. Basilone’s recognition of his status as a hero contrasts with his own internal struggles, reflecting the dissonance between the heroic ideal and the stark realities of violence. This juxtaposition challenges conventional notions of heroism, inviting viewers to question the glorification of wartime actions.

“Basilone” also examines the camaraderie and bond among soldiers. The interactions within the Marine unit reveal the emotional connections formed amidst the chaos of battle. These relationships provide a counterbalance to the brutality, offering moments of humanity and vulnerability. The episode suggests that these connections are not just a means of survival but a source of hope and resilience.

The depiction of the enemy, in this case, the Japanese forces, is another thought-provoking aspect of the episode. While the portrayal remains mostly one-dimensional, the inclusion of scenes that hint at the Japanese perspective adds a layer of complexity. These moments humanise the opposition, raising questions about the shared human experiences of soldiers on both sides.

The technical aspects of the episode, including cinematography and sound design, play a pivotal role in crafting the narrative. The use of handheld cameras and intense close-ups creates a sense of immediacy, making viewers feel like they are in the midst of the action. The stark contrast between the lush, serene landscapes of Guadalcanal and the brutality of battle further underscores the jarring nature of war.

One criticism of the episode lies in its limited representation of diverse perspectives. While the focus on Sgt. Basilone is engaging, the experiences of other soldiers, especially those from different backgrounds, remain under-explored. This narrow lens potentially diminishes the comprehensive understanding of the war’s impact on a diverse array of individuals.

In conclusion, “Basilone,” the second episode of “The Pacific,” is a masterful depiction of the multifaceted nature of war. Through its exploration of heroism, camaraderie, and the psychological toll of battle, the episode delivers a visceral and thought-provoking narrative. Its technical craftsmanship, while immersive, might benefit from a broader perspective. Overall, “Basilone” remains a compelling entry in the miniseries that challenges traditional narratives of war while honouring the sacrifices of those who endured it.